Tikka masala, butter chicken and korma are the three curries people order when they want something creamy and not too hot. They look alike in the takeaway box, but they come from different places and taste different. Here is how to tell them apart, and which one to pick.
The short answer
- Korma is the mildest: meat braised in yoghurt with fragrant spices, often with cream and nuts in curry houses
- Butter chicken is chicken tikka in a smooth, buttery tomato sauce, mild and a little sweet
- Tikka masala is chicken tikka in a creamy tomato and onion sauce, with a bit more spice
- Butter chicken and murgh makhani are the same dish
- All three are usually mild to medium, so they are good first curries
Side by side
| Korma | Butter chicken | Tikka masala | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where it comes from | The Mughal kitchens of North India | Delhi, in the 1950s | Most likely Britain, though this is disputed |
| The chicken | Braised in the sauce | Chicken tikka, grilled or seared first | Chicken tikka, grilled or seared first |
| The sauce | Yoghurt, fried onions and whole spices, often cream and nuts | Tomato, butter and cream, often cashews | Tomato, onion and cream |
| Taste | Fragrant, gentle, rich | Buttery, smooth, slightly sweet | Tangy, creamy, a little spicier |
| Colour | Pale gold | Orange | Orange to red |
| Heat | Mildest | Mild | Mild to medium |
What is korma?
Korma means braising, and it is one of the oldest dishes on the menu. It first appears in Mughal cookery books in the 1600s: meat seared in ghee, then cooked slowly with yoghurt and spices like cardamom, cloves and mace until the sauce is thick. The British curry house korma is sweeter and creamier, usually with cream, ground almonds or coconut.
Aamna cooks it the traditional way. Her classic chicken korma has no cream and no nuts. The richness comes from yoghurt and onions fried until crisp and crushed to crumbs, with mace, star anise and a splash of kewra water for fragrance. Her easy chicken korma does the same in one pan in 30 minutes.
What is butter chicken?
Butter chicken is murgh makhani: murgh means chicken and makhani means made with butter. The best-known story says it was created at the Moti Mahal restaurant in Delhi in the 1950s, when leftover tandoori chicken was stirred into a tomato sauce rich with butter. Who exactly invented it is still argued over, and in 2024 two Delhi restaurant families took the question to court.
Aamna’s butter chicken sears the chicken, then cooks tomatoes with butter, cashews, a little sugar and a splash of vinegar, blends it smooth and finishes it with cream and kasuri methi. Her better butter chicken is the restaurant-style version, with chicken tikka roasted in a very hot oven until charred.
What is tikka masala?
Chicken tikka masala is pieces of marinated chicken tikka in a creamy, spiced tomato sauce. Its origin is disputed. The most famous claim comes from the Shish Mahal restaurant in Glasgow, and food historians generally agree it was created in Britain, probably by a Bangladeshi chef, though some say it is a Punjabi dish. In 2001 the Foreign Secretary Robin Cook called it “a true British national dish”.
Aamna’s chicken tikka masala marinates the chicken in yoghurt, lemon and spices, sears it in a hot pan, then finishes it in an onion and tomato sauce with double cream and kasuri methi. For a vegetarian version, try her paneer tikka masala.
Classic Chicken Korma
A mild, classic chicken korma made with yoghurt, crispy fried onions and whole spices, finished with kewra water.
Butter Chicken: A Timeless Classic
Classic murgh makhani: tender chicken in a buttery tomato sauce with cream, cashews and kasuri methi.
Chicken Tikka Masala
Chicken tikka seared in a hot pan, then simmered in a creamy tomato sauce with double cream and fenugreek.
Butter chicken vs tikka masala
These two are the easiest to mix up, because both start with chicken tikka and both have a creamy tomato sauce. The difference is in the sauce. Butter chicken is built on butter and tomatoes and blended smooth, so it tastes richer and sweeter. Tikka masala has more onion and spice in the sauce, so it is a little tangier and hotter.
Korma vs tikka masala
Korma is paler and milder, with a yoghurt or cream sauce and fragrant rather than spicy flavours. Tikka masala is tomato-based, more savoury and slightly hotter. If you are unsure about spice, start with korma. If you want a bit more flavour without real heat, go for tikka masala.
What about pasanda and makhani?
- Pasanda is the closest thing to a korma: slices of flattened lamb or chicken in a mild, creamy sauce with ground almonds.
- Makhani on a menu means butter chicken, or a dish made in the same buttery tomato sauce, like paneer makhani.
- Dal makhani is black lentils cooked slowly with butter and cream. Try Aamna’s black dal.
Which one should you choose?
- For kids or anyone new to curry: korma.
- For something rich and a little sweet: butter chicken.
- For more flavour with only a little heat: tikka masala.
- For something spicier: see the curry heat guide.
FAQs
Is butter chicken the same as tikka masala?
No. Both use chicken tikka, but butter chicken has a smooth, buttery tomato sauce and tikka masala has a tangier sauce with more onion and spice.
What is butter chicken called in India?
Murgh makhani. Murgh means chicken and makhani means made with butter.
Which is milder, korma or butter chicken?
Korma is usually the milder of the two, though both are gentle.
What is korma sauce made of?
Traditionally yoghurt, fried onions and spices like cardamom and mace. Curry houses add cream and ground nuts.
Is tikka masala Indian or British?
Its origin is disputed, but most food historians think it was created in Britain.
Can I make these without cream?
Yes. Aamna’s kormas use yoghurt and crushed fried onions instead of cream.