Mutton is meat from an older sheep, but in Pakistani and Indian cooking the word usually means goat. Here is how mutton, lamb, hogget and goat differ, which cuts to buy for curry, and how long each one takes to cook, with the times from Aamna’s own recipes.
Mutton at a glance
- In the UK, mutton is sheep over about two years old
- Lamb is under a year old, and hogget is in between
- In Pakistan and India, mutton usually means goat
- Mutton is darker and stronger than lamb and needs slow cooking
- Most mutton curries take 1 hour 30 minutes to 2 hours in a pot, or about 30 minutes in a pressure cooker
What does mutton mean?
Mutton is meat from a sheep that is older than a lamb. That is the simple answer, and it is the one you will get from a British butcher or a dictionary. The trouble is that the word means something slightly different depending on who is using it, and that is why so many people search for it.
In the UK, sheep meat is sold by the age of the animal. In Pakistani and Indian kitchens, and at a lot of South Asian butchers here in Britain, mutton usually means goat. Both uses are correct in their own world, and once you know which one a recipe means, the cooking makes sense.
Lamb, hogget and mutton in the UK
British farmers and butchers tell the age of a sheep by its teeth, so the names below are a guide rather than exact birthdays.
| Name | Roughly how old | What it is like |
|---|---|---|
| Lamb | Under a year, with no adult front teeth | Pale, tender and mild. The most common sheep meat in UK supermarkets. |
| Hogget | Between about one and two years | Darker and a little firmer than lamb, with more flavour. |
| Mutton | Over about two years | Dark red, firmer and much stronger tasting. Best cooked slowly. |
The older the animal, the darker the meat, the stronger the flavour and the more connective tissue it has. That connective tissue is why mutton needs long, gentle cooking. Given time, it melts into the sauce and makes a curry rich and silky. Rushed, it stays chewy.
Why mutton often means goat in South Asian cooking
Across Pakistan, India and much of South and South East Asia, the everyday red meat is goat, and in English it is usually called mutton. So a “mutton curry” on a menu in Karachi or Delhi is most likely goat. In Urdu and Hindi you will also hear bakre ka gosht, which means goat meat, or just gosht, which means meat.
In the UK it depends on the butcher. Some halal and South Asian butchers sell goat as mutton, some sell older sheep as mutton, and some use the word for both. If the label just says mutton, ask whether it is goat or sheep. Both work in the recipes on this site.
Goat, lamb or mutton: which should you use?
| Meat | Flavour | Texture | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Goat | Lean with a gentle, slightly gamey taste | Firm, needs slow cooking | Everyday curries, paya, namkeen gosht, biryani |
| Lamb | Mild and rich, with more fat | Tender, cooks faster | Roasts, karahi, mandi, kabuli pulao |
| Mutton (older sheep) | Deep and strong | Firm, needs the longest cooking | Slow curries, nihari, rogan josh |
If a recipe says mutton and you only have lamb, use it. It will usually be tender sooner, so start checking it about 20 to 30 minutes early. If you swap the other way, from lamb to goat or older mutton, give it longer and keep a little extra hot water to hand.
Mutton cuts and how long they take
These are the cuts Aamna cooks with most, with the times from her recipes. Times are for a pot on the hob with the lid on, after the meat has been browned.
| Cut | What it is | Try it in | Cooking time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bone-in pieces | Mixed pieces from the shoulder and leg, cut through the bone | Classic mutton curry, namkeen gosht | 1 hour 30 minutes to 2 hours |
| Boneless pieces | Diced shoulder or leg | Eid mutton bhuna, chana dal gosht | About 1 hour to 1 hour 30 minutes |
| Chops | Rib or loin chops, often cut through for curries | Mutton chop curry, mutton chops biryani, fried chops | About 1 hour 30 minutes to 2 hours |
| Shanks | The lower leg, full of connective tissue | Nihari, kabuli pulao | About 2 hours |
| Shoulder (whole) | A big, fatty joint that roasts beautifully | Lamb shoulder mandi | About 3 hours |
| Neck | Cheap, rich and tender when slow cooked | Roasted lamb neck | About 2 hours |
| Trotters (paya) | The feet, mostly bone and gelatine | Mutton paya | 3 to 4 hours |
| Liver (kaleji) | Soft offal that toughens if boiled hard | Kaleji | Gentle simmer, see the recipe |
Cooking times vary with the age of the animal, the size of the pieces and your pan, so go by feel: the meat is ready when a piece pulls away from the bone easily or breaks apart when pressed with a spoon.
How to cook mutton so it is tender
- Brown it well. Fry the marinated meat in hot oil for 5 to 10 minutes until it changes colour all over. This builds flavour before any water goes in.
- Use a little acid. Yoghurt, tomatoes or a splash of vinegar help. Aamna adds malt vinegar to her comforting mutton curry and mutton chop curry.
- Cook it low and slow. Once the water is in, bring it to the boil, cover, and turn it right down. A gentle simmer is better than a rolling boil.
- Don’t add too much water. Just enough to almost cover the meat. You can always add more hot water later, and less water means a richer sauce.
- Finish uncovered. When the meat is tender, take the lid off and turn up the heat for a few minutes, stirring, until the oil rises to the top. That is the sign of a properly cooked curry.
Cooking mutton in a pressure cooker
A pressure cooker cuts the time a lot. Aamna’s comforting mutton curry uses bone-in mutton and cooks under pressure for about 30 minutes, compared with 1 hour 30 minutes to 2 hours in an ordinary pot. Brown the meat and cook the onions first with the lid off, then add the water and seal it.
Every pressure cooker is different, so check your manual for timings and the amount of liquid it needs. If the meat is not quite tender when you open it, simmer it with the lid off for a few more minutes rather than sealing it again for a long time.
Buying mutton in the UK
- Halal and South Asian butchers are the easiest place to find goat and mutton, and they will cut it into curry pieces for you.
- Ask whether it is goat or sheep, and whether it is from a young or older animal.
- For curries, ask for bone-in pieces from the shoulder or leg. The bones add flavour and body to the sauce.
- Supermarkets mostly sell lamb. Lamb shoulder, neck and shanks are good stand-ins for mutton in slow-cooked dishes.
- Frozen mutton and goat are fine for curries. Thaw it in the fridge overnight before cooking.
Mutton recipes to start with
| Recipe | Why try it |
|---|---|
| Classic mutton curry | The everyday curry: onions, whole spices and a slow simmer. |
| Mutton chop curry | Chops in a rich onion and tomato gravy. |
| Mutton paya | Trotters slow-cooked into a gelatinous breakfast curry. |
| Namkeen gosht | A simple salt and pepper mutton dish with very few spices. |
| Mughlai white mutton handi | Mutton in a creamy yoghurt and cashew sauce. Mild and rich. |
| Mutton madras | For people who like more heat. |
| Mutton chops biryani | A biryani for a special occasion. |
Mutton FAQs
Is mutton lamb?
Not quite. In the UK, lamb is a sheep under a year old and mutton is a sheep over about two years old. Both are sheep meat, but mutton is darker, firmer and stronger in flavour.
Is mutton goat?
In South Asian cooking, usually yes. In Pakistan and India the word mutton normally means goat meat. In British butchers it can mean either goat or older sheep, so it is worth asking.
What does mutton taste like?
Richer and stronger than lamb, with a deeper, slightly gamey flavour. Goat is leaner than lamb and has a gentle gamey taste of its own.
What is gosht?
Gosht is the Urdu and Hindi word for meat, and on its own it usually means mutton or lamb. You will sometimes see it written as ghost, as in ghost fry. Chana dal gosht is mutton cooked with split chickpeas, and namkeen gosht means salted meat.
How long does mutton take to cook?
In a covered pot, most mutton curries take 1 hour 30 minutes to 2 hours. Shanks and whole shoulders take 2 to 3 hours, and trotters for paya take 3 to 4 hours. In a pressure cooker, bone-in mutton is usually tender in about 30 minutes.
Why is my mutton still tough?
It almost always needs more time. Add a splash of hot water, cover, and keep it on a gentle simmer. Boiling it hard makes it tougher, so keep the heat low.
Can I use lamb instead of mutton?
Yes. Lamb works in every mutton recipe on this site. It cooks faster, so check it early.